Are You Listening?!?!

Skillful listening provides several irrefutable advantages: It makes you a more efficient negotiator, a more effective manager, a more persuasive salesperson, and – best of all, perhaps – a more likeable person.

Being an inept listener has several irrefutable disadvantages: It makes you a bully negotiator (which means the deals you close will eventually fall apart), a bossy boss (whose employees will secretly do what they can to see you fail), a pushy salesperson (which means you won’t have many repeat customers), and the least likely to be invited back guest at the party.

Case in point: Several weeks ago, MN, BB, and I had lunch with PG, a successful direct-mail copywriter. PG, usually unapproachable, wanted to talk to us about collaborating on a few projects. We were very interested… until he started speaking.

He began by telling us all about… well… us!

I don’t know where he got his information, but it was mostly wrong and/or outdated. When we tried to correct him, he shook his head dismissively and kept on talking.

He then spent what seemed like an eternity telling us what we needed. Once again, everything he said was based on false or obsolete information. He had no idea about our current needs. And, again, when we tried to correct him, he kept on talking.

Finally, he paused. This was our chance to speak up, but we were so flabbergasted we just sat there silently, mouths agape.

So he smiled a big ignoramus smile and begin the third part of what I’m sure he thought was a marvelous presentation. He gave us half a dozen ideas for solving problems we no longer had and pitched us on opportunities we had long ago taken advantage of.

I swear to you… he never asked us a single question. He was animated. His voice boomed and then quivered for dramatic effect. He gestured with his hands. He sat forward with confidence. (Or was it impudence?)

But he never looked at our faces to try to discern whether his monologue was hitting a chord. Had he done so, even for a second, he would have realized it was going very badly.

Here’s the thing: We came to that lunch 99% determined to do business with him. We left sure that we wouldn’t.

And the sad thing is that he will never know why. He certainly won’t ask.

Now what I’m about to say may seem like braggadocio. So let me preface it by admitting that I am not a natural listener. I prefer to talk… to the point of cutting people off in mid-sentence to give them the benefit of hearing me.

At least I used to do that. But I have learned from my mistakes. And I have made some improvements. And that’s why I’m excited to tell you how I just recently actively practiced the art of listening and was nicely rewarded for it.

Here’s what happened…

I was attempting to finalize the purchase of two very desirable oil paintings – one for my private collection and one for one of my galleries.

The price for the two had already been negotiated down to $35,000. I was okay with that. But I had an argument ready – a good argument – for paying about $5,000 less.

I was prepared to “settle” for $32,000, and I wanted to launch right into my argument. But then I remembered the virtue of listening. So instead of going into my rant, I said, “I know we’ve arrived at a price of $35,000 and I understand how we came to that. But I’m still thinking it might be a little high. Can you tell me why you think it should be $35,000?”

He did.

He gave me four reasons, two of which were solid and two of which were weak. I told him that I agreed with the two good reasons. And then I used only bits of my prepared argument to refute the two weaker ones.

Again, I asked him what he thought about what I had just said.

He said he appreciated the fact that I understood his two good reasons. He also said that he felt my two arguments made sense. He then offered to reduce the price to $29,500!

Making my case after I had listened to his gave me an advantage. One that saved me a significant amount of money.

So whenever I have an argument to make, I’m going to keep reminding myself to:

  1. Shut up.
  2. Ask a question. (A strategic question.)
  3. Listen to the answer.
  4. Summarize what the other person said before I present my case.

What I’ve learned is that restating the other person’s thoughts and feelings ensures him that I understand him. As a result, it makes him more open to my ideas. (Note: I have to be careful not to devalue his ideas/feelings by the words I choose to summarize them.)

I’m going to remember that the ostensible purpose of many conversations – even business conversations – isn’t always what it appears to be. Sometimes people just need to be heard. They want to tell you their stories. They want you to listen to them.

Let them talk. Then ask them more questions. Know where you are going. And let them lead you there.