South African Genocide: Is It Really a Thing?

I’m sure you’ve heard about President Trump’s meeting with Cyril Ramaphosa, South Africa’s president, on May 21. Trump booby-trapped the former businessman by showing him a photo of crosses, symbolizing the number of White farmers who, Trump said, were murdered by Black South Africans who apparently want to Make South Africa Black Again.
Trump was chastised by the Leftist/Liberal media for embarrassing the guy. And he was subsequently criticized by the same for giving political asylum to 50 White South Africans who’d rather live in the US than continue living down there.
Now, there’s a debate about whether these killings are part of a policy of genocide that some South Africans are undeniably promoting, or whether they are the just rewards dealt to colonizers who have no right to be in South Africa at all.
One of the members of the Monday afternoon discussion group I belong to is South African, and he says the term genocide is not correct – that, for the most part, the country is still a country of laws and that these murders were being prosecuted and that he for one doesn’t feel particularly unsafe living there.
I’ve been to South Africa a half-dozen times for meetings with a business we’ve had there for nearly 25 years. I never felt unsafe. But to be fair, I’ve always been in the business and/or tourist zones of Cape Town and Johannesburg, not in the isolation of the rural countryside where the murders have taken place.
To be sure, our South African employees (90% White) do take precautions when driving to and from work. The same sort of precautions that our employees in downtown Baltimore take when they pass through neighborhoods where the bulk of muggings take place.
But my friends and colleagues in South Africa say that, although they don’t believe the government is in any way engaged in genocide, they are concerned that since Ramaphosa took office, life for all the citizens of the country has been getting worse, with a near-bankrupt government, a failing educational system, a failed social support system, and an economy that is getting weaker every day.
Here are some of the facts:
* South Africa has and has had the largest White population of any settler state in Africa.
* 73% of privately owned land in South Africa is White-owned, despite White people comprising about 7% of the population.
* There are two White populations in South Africa. Dutch descendants who have been there for 400 years and see themselves as South Africans, not Dutch. And descendants of British settlers who came to South Africa in 1820.
* Whites are indeed being murdered. However, the actual numbers are more modest than some claims suggest. There were 32 farm murders in 2024, down from 50 in 2023. In the most recent quarter, only 12 farm murders were recorded, with just one victim being an actual farmer.
* The revolution to overthrow the White-dominated government was violent, but the overthrow itself came through a political process that was bipartisan. White South Africans, as well as Blacks, supported Nelson Mandela as a move towards a multiracial politic.
* Close to 70,000 South Africans have expressed interest in moving to the US following Washington’s offer to resettle people from the country’s Afrikaner community.
* Crime in South Africa is indeed crazy. The country has one of the world’s highest murder rates, with an average of 72 murders a day in a country of 60 million people. However, as in the US, most of the victims are Black. Murders of White farmers represent less than 1% of all the murders.
With all that information in mind, I was interested in this take on the question by Lara Logan, who was a supporter of Nelson Mandela and has been a journalist in South Africa since Mandela came to power in the 1990s. (Start watching at minute 4:30.)